1. Token Standards and Why Each Emerged
A token standard is a common smart-contract interface (defining mandatory functions like transfer or balanceOf and event logs) so wallets, custodians, exchanges, and apps can interact with any compliant token without custom code. New standards emerged whenever existing ones hit architectural or regulatory bottlenecks:
A. Core Retail & DeFi Standards (Ethereum / EVM)
- ERC-20 (Fungible Tokens — 2015): Created to represent interchangeable units where every token is identical.
- Why it came up: Early Ethereum tokens had incompatible function names, forcing exchanges to write custom adapters for every coin.
- Use cases: Stablecoins (USDC, USDT), utility tokens, governance tokens, and fractionalized shares.
- Limitation for finance: Has zero built-in identity, KYC, freeze, or forced-recovery mechanisms—anyone with a private key can transfer tokens anywhere.
- ERC-721 (Non-Fungible Tokens / NFTs — 2018): Tracks ownership of unique, indivisible items via distinct
tokenIds.- Why it came up: ERC-20 couldn’t represent unique assets where Item A is worth more than Item B.
- Use cases: Real estate deeds, luxury goods provenance, unique bonds/invoices, and digital art.
- ERC-1155 (Multi-Token Standard — 2018): Manages fungible, semi-fungible, and non-fungible tokens inside a single smart contract, supporting batch transfers.
- Why it came up: Deploying a separate ERC-721 contract per asset class and transferring items one by one was prohibitively expensive in gas fees.
- Use cases: Gaming items, event tickets, and multi-tranche financial portfolios (e.g., different share classes or bond series in one contract).
- ERC-4626 (Tokenized Vault Standard — 2021): Standardizes yield-bearing vault shares that represent a claim on an underlying ERC-20 asset.
- Why it came up: Every lending protocol or money-market fund calculated deposit/redemption yields differently, creating integration risks.
- Use cases: Tokenized money-market funds (like BlackRock’s BUIDL or Ondo’s USDY), DeFi lending pools, and auto-compounding yield products.
B. Institutional & Regulated Real-World Asset (RWA) Standards
- ERC-1400 (Security Token Standard — 2018): A suite of standards adding partitions (tranches like restricted vs. unrestricted shares), on-chain document attachment (prospectuses), and issuer forced-transfer/redemption controls.
- Why it came up: Financial institutions needed a way to enforce SEC lock-up periods and court-ordered clawbacks on-chain. (Note: Remained a draft standard with fragmented vendor implementations.)
- ERC-3643 / T-REX (Compliance-Aware Permissioned Token — 2021): The dominant institutional RWA standard (finalized EIP). It pairs an ERC-20 interface with an on-chain identity system (ONCHAINID) and modular Compliance Contracts.
- Why it came up: ERC-1400 lacked a standardized decentralized identity layer. ERC-3643 checks both sender and receiver eligibility (KYC, accreditation, jurisdiction caps) before executing every transfer, and includes
freezeandrecoveryAddressfunctions. - Use cases: Regulated equities, tokenized bonds, private equity funds, and institutional real estate.
- Why it came up: ERC-1400 lacked a standardized decentralized identity layer. ERC-3643 checks both sender and receiver eligibility (KYC, accreditation, jurisdiction caps) before executing every transfer, and includes
- ERC-3525 (Semi-Fungible Token — 2022): Combines ERC-721’s unique ID with ERC-20’s quantitative math (
value), allowing tokens with matchingslotattributes to be split or merged.- Use cases: Structured financial products, insurance policies, vesting schedules, and fixed-income bonds with varying maturities/coupons.
- CMTAT (CMTA Token): Developed by Switzerland’s Capital Markets and Technology Association to align strictly with Swiss DLT securities law (pause, freeze, and debt/equity lifecycle hooks).
C. Non-EVM Ecosystem Standards
- SPL / Token-2022 (Solana): Unlike Ethereum, Solana doesn’t deploy new smart contract code per token; it uses a shared system program. Token-2022 adds native extensions directly at the protocol level—such as transfer hooks (for KYC checks), permanent delegates (for institutional clawbacks), and confidential transfers.
- Stellar Native Assets (Protocol-Level): Stellar doesn’t require smart contracts to issue tokens. Issuers use built-in protocol flags (
AUTH_REQUIRED,AUTH_REVOCABLE,AUTH_CLAWBACK_ENABLED) to approve trustlines, freeze accounts, or claw back regulated assets.
2. What Are Solana and Stellar?
Both Solana and Stellar are high-speed, low-cost Layer-1 blockchains that DTCC integrated alongside Ethereum-compatible networks—but they were built with very different architectures and target use cases:
| Feature | Solana | Stellar |
| Launched | 2020 (founded by Anatoly Yakovenko) | 2014 (co-founded by Jed McCaleb, co-founder of Ripple) |
| Core Purpose | High-throughput, general-purpose smart contract platform for institutional trading, DeFi, and consumer apps. | Purpose-built payment and asset-issuance network connecting banks, payment rails, and cross-border currencies. |
| Consensus & Speed | Proof of History (PoH) + Proof of Stake (PoS); processes thousands of transactions per second (TPS) with ~400ms block times and sub-cent fees. | Stellar Consensus Protocol (SCP) (a Federated Byzantine Agreement model); settles in 3–5 seconds for fractions of a cent without mining or staking rewards. |
| Smart Contracts & Compliance | Executes parallelized Rust/C smart contracts. Uses Token-2022 extensions (transfer hooks, permanent delegate) to enforce institutional compliance at high speed. | Historically relied on protocol-level native controls (trustlines, account freeze, clawback) rather than complex code, though it added Soroban (WebAssembly smart contracts) in 2024. |
| Why DTCC & Institutions Use It | Chosen by Visa, Franklin Templeton, BlackRock, and DTCC for high-frequency capital markets, on-chain order books, and real-time collateral settlement where latency matters. | Chosen by Franklin Templeton (BENJI money market fund), MoneyGram, WisdomTree, and DTCC for cross-border settlement, stablecoins, and regulated fund shares due to its native issuer controls. |